Last night I debated the following statement, made by a freind, “If you think DVDs will be around in a year you are mistaken.” His quip was made in response to my voicing my excitement for getting a super-sweet Blu-Ray drive. I initially disregarded his gaul and went merrily along in my usual bliss of technical ignorance. As the night went on, our discussion became more heated, with him eventually disregarding me as an Apple Fanboy - something about me drinking lots of Starbucks in my square framed glasses. Oh dear.
I still think DVDs will be around for some time; besides, where are people to drive their mid-life BMW if not to Blockbuster on Friday night? I digress, but I genuinely give the format, HD or no, at least five years of lifespan. In an attempt to defend that, let us now regard the state of digital movie delivery.
1. My challenger claimed that X-Box 360 had “cornered the market on young people downloading movies.” Already, in his mind, reducing DVDs as useless as that Spin Doctor’s CD you know you own. In their defense, Microsoft is offering a very interesting package for movie delivery, via their Live services, assuming you own their console. The technical details and pricing gets fairly convoluted, but it seems like a reasonable deal. A Standard Definition (SD) movie rental is $3 to $4, depending on its newness; High Definition (HD) rental is $4.50 to $6. The problem with this solution is two-fold: First, it means I have to buy an X-Box 360 in order to get started. Second, I have to use Microsoft Points, and nothing is more frustrating than the idea that MS would be in charge of any type of currency. Ever.
2. The next argument was that Netflix Instant Rentals are “the main way people are using Netflix.” I am a satisfied customer and have only heard of this peripherally. Upon trying to watch Short Circuit instantly, I was greeted with “Our apologies — instant watching is currently not supported for Macintosh”. Me and my square framed glasses are hurt by that, Mr. Netflix man. In addition to this striking blow, the movie selection for Instant Viewing was disappointing - sort of like browsing the collection of someone that you have nothing in common with, in the mid ’90s.
3. I tried to defend my case by pointing to the Itunes movie rental debacle currently happening. While Apple has conquered / destroyed the economy of music, their attempt to do the same with movies has not gone very well so far. For starters, you have to have an Apple TV box to rent HD movies. But you can rent movies at SD on your PC, Mac, or Ipod for less money. SD defeats the purpose for me and the last thing I want is to watch movies exclusively on my computer. In addition, when the movie houses made their deals with Itunes, they insisted on a 24 hour window of functionality. That means if I rent it, Elle throws a fit, and life takes over for a day - no dice - movie gone. No thanks so far for this Fanboy, Apple.
There are, of course, other options available via the internets: CinemaNow (PC only), Vudu (must buy their hardware), etc. None of these ideas really do much for actually integrating “on demand” movies to the living room. Which leads to the next new thing: TVs that hook directly to the internet! I had a hard time finding information about this on a cursory look, but I will dig deeper.
So, for me there is not a great way to abandon DVDs just yet. Perhaps in a couple of years, the new technologies built directly into the television will persuade me to stop ogling the Playstation 3. But for now I love me some Blu-Ray; more to come.